top of page
Writer's pictureAshley Yabut

Exploring the Tragic Elements in High Fantasy: Why We Love Stories That Break Our Hearts

Updated: Oct 11

High fantasy has always captivated readers with its grand settings, complex characters, and epic battles. But one element that often stands out, deeply resonating with audiences, is tragedy. The tragic elements in high fantasy add emotional depth and a sense of realism to otherwise fantastical tales. They remind us of our own struggles and triumphs, making the stories more relatable and impactful. In this blog, we will explore why we love tragic stories in high fantasy, using both classic and modern examples to illustrate this timeless appeal.



Defeated Fantasy Hero


From ancient myths to contemporary novels, tragic elements have played a crucial role in storytelling. They evoke powerful emotions, create memorable characters, and leave lasting impressions on readers. In high fantasy, these elements are not just about sorrow and loss but about resilience, hope, and the human spirit's capacity to overcome adversity.


Historical Context

1. Classic Literature Examples:

  • "The Lord of the Rings" by J.R.R. Tolkien One of the most iconic high fantasy series, "The Lord of the Rings," is filled with moments of profound tragedy. The fall of Boromir, the suffering of Frodo, and the haunting fate of Gollum are just a few examples. These tragic elements highlight the heavy cost of heroism and the pervasive presence of evil.

  • "The Silmarillion" by J.R.R. Tolkien In "The Silmarillion," the tales of Beren and Lúthien and the tragic fall of the city of Gondolin showcase the beauty and sorrow intertwined in Tolkien's world. These stories reflect the deep connection between love, loss, and the eternal struggle against darkness.


2. Myths and Folklore: Tragedy in high fantasy often draws from ancient myths and folklore. The Greek myths, with tales like Orpheus and Eurydice or the tragic fate of Oedipus, serve as foundational examples of how tragedy has been used to convey complex human emotions and moral lessons.


Modern High Fantasy

1. Contemporary Works:

  • "A Song of Ice and Fire" by George R.R. Martin George R.R. Martin's series is renowned for its relentless tragedy. The Red Wedding, the downfall of noble characters like Eddard Stark, and the torment of Jon Snow are prime examples. Martin's willingness to kill beloved characters underscores the harsh realities of his world, making the moments of victory all the more poignant.

  • "Throne of Glass" by Sarah J. Maas In Sarah J. Maas's "Throne of Glass" series, protagonist Celaena Sardothien endures immense suffering and loss. Her journey through betrayal, slavery, and personal sacrifice illustrates the strength of the human spirit. Each tragic event she faces shapes her into a resilient and formidable character.


Emotional Impact

Tragic elements in high fantasy create emotional depth, making readers more invested in the characters and their journeys. The suffering and losses endured by characters like Frodo, Jon Snow, and Celaena Sardothien make their eventual triumphs and moments of joy more meaningful.


1. Character Development: Tragedy often serves as a catalyst for character development. It forces characters to confront their weaknesses, make difficult choices, and grow in ways they never imagined. This evolution is compelling and relatable, as it mirrors the human experience of facing and overcoming adversity.

2. Reader Engagement: Readers are drawn to tragic stories because they evoke a wide range of emotions. The heartbreak, sorrow, and catharsis experienced through these tales create a deep connection between the reader and the narrative. This emotional engagement keeps readers coming back for more, eager to see how the characters navigate their challenges.


 

Writing Tragedy


1. Tips for Writing Tragic Scenes:

  • Balance Tragedy with Hope: While tragedy is powerful, it's essential to balance it with moments of hope and resilience. This contrast makes the story more compelling and prevents it from becoming overwhelmingly bleak.

  • Develop Complex Characters: Tragic events are more impactful when they happen to well-developed characters. Invest time in creating multidimensional characters that readers care about.

  • Create Meaningful Losses: Tragedy should serve a purpose in the narrative. Ensure that each tragic event contributes to character growth or advances the plot in a significant way.


2. Balancing Tragedy and Resolution:

  • Tragic stories should also offer a sense of resolution or redemption. This balance provides a satisfying conclusion and reinforces the themes of resilience and hope.


 

Tragedy in high fantasy enriches the narrative, providing emotional depth and creating unforgettable stories. From the classic tales of Tolkien to the modern sagas of Martin and Maas, tragedy continues to captivate readers and remind us of the enduring power of storytelling. By exploring the tragic elements in high fantasy, we gain a deeper appreciation for the resilience of the human spirit and the beauty of hope in the face of adversity.


If you love stories that break your heart and uplift your soul, watch out for 'Dawn's Veil' to experience a tale of tragedy, resilience, and hope. Join our newsletter for exclusive insights and updates on the journey of crafting this epic fantasy.

Comments


bottom of page